MB Trading : 1 Trades: 9.9 pips
GO Markets : 1 Trades: 10.1 pips
InterbankFx : 1 Trades: 10.1 pips
InterbankFx AU : 1 Trades: 10.2 pips
FxPro : 1 Trades: 10.2 pips
Alpari UK (Mini-1) : 1 Trades: 10.3 pips
Alpari UK (Classic): 1 Trades: 10.2 pips
FXDD : 1 Trades: 10.0 pips
AxiTrader : 1 Trades: 9.8 pips
FxSol : 1 Trades: 10.0 pips
TRADE DETAILS: Open Close Profit
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MB Trading S1 Buy: 16:13:44 1.35264 -> 16:45:14 1.35363 9.9 pips
GO Markets S1 Buy: 23:13:42 1.35267 -> 23:49:31 1.35368 10.1 pips
InterbankFx S1 Buy: 21:13:39 1.35270 -> 21:49:38 1.35371 10.1 pips
InterbankFx AU S1 Buy: 21:13:39 1.35269 -> 21:49:38 1.35371 10.2 pips
FxPro S1 Buy: 23:13:42 1.35264 -> 23:49:05 1.35366 10.2 pips
Alpari UK (Mini-1) S1 Buy: 22:07:05 1.35275 -> 22:49:38 1.35378 10.3 pips
Alpari UK (Classic) S1 Buy: 22:07:05 1.35275 -> 22:49:38 1.35377 10.2 pips
FXDD S1 Buy: 23:06:59 1.35271 -> 23:49:40 1.35371 10.0 pips
AxiTrader S1 Buy: 23:07:18 1.35274 -> 23:49:37 1.35372 9.8 pips
FxSol S1 Buy: 16:02:54 1.35280 -> 16:59:35 1.35380 10.0 pips
Alpari UK classic
S1 Buy 10.5 pips
Every account got a trade today, although the FxSol trade took a little longer to close.
hell yeah!!!!
ActivTrades:
1st: +10.1
2nd: +6.6
FinFx (demo) = 9.8 pips
InterbankFx (demo) = 10.2 pips
I’m completely disappointed. ActivTrades – 80 pips on my account ! I think I will never understand these differences whereas I’m on a VPS in UK with a UK broker
S1 Buy: 22:04 1.3528 -> 22:52 1.3538 +10 pips
S2 Buy: 23:52 1.3525 -> 03:33 1.3446 – 79 pips
I think I will create different broker accounts as of today to disperse risks.
Anyone has the same performance ?
Hi Silver,
I’m surprised by that result. I didn’t get any losses today. I only got one S1 trade, but didn’t get any S2 trades.
Is there a chance your MT4 terminal lost connection during the trade? Might be worthwhile checking the MT4 log just in case. It is possible the trade didn’t close in profit if the MT4 terminal was not connected at the time.
SiegFried can you tell me when your S2 has been opened and closed? It seems that ActivTrades has been the only broker with which a s2 trade has been opened
In my journal tab I’ve got different “login” messages at 04:00 am, but I’ve got this message everyday, at the same time, it should be an auto deconnection on ActivTrades side.
ATC -> 10 pips.
Fxcbs -> 10 pips.
hi Silver!
trade one: 22.05 – 22.49 (long)
trade two: 23.41 – 00.45 (long)
sorry for your minus 79 pips :/
what Server du you use Silver??
ActivTrades-Server, the normal one with 4 digits, not the InterBank one
…I’m not an expert But I recommend An Interbank Account and a Server not from your Broker..
I have an independent server SiegFried from a VPS provider not an ActivTrades one
Oh, ok.
S1 Buy: 22:04 1.3528 -> 22:52 1.3538 +10 pips
S2 Buy: 23:52 1.3525 -> 03:33 1.3446 –79 pips
these are my results on activtrades.uk
no vps, home-pc running overnight from germany
wiped out 4 weeks of profits 🙁
Can you tell me if you’ve got different login messages at 4:00 am every day ?
there are several “37584:login” entries in the journal that night at 4:34 am local time, this was one hour after trade ran into stop loss.
Pepperstone:
S2 Buy trade:
00:52 – 07:46
-85.40 points
Hello men
I have got -88 pips on my live FinFX account too. It was very strange.I have sent email to support and waiting for request.I dont understand the reason of such different results.
S2 Buy 00:52 1.35247 -> 04:47 1.34367 -88pips 🙁
@ silver: No i dont have…
oh it seems that i get tonight my first bad trade.. a very bad trade :/ f*#*%
what about you?
Strange how some of us got a loss.
From what I’ve read the losing trade was a S2 trade that occurred on the ActivTrades, FinFx and Pepperstone brokers.
I didn’t get that S2 trade signal on any of my accounts. Perhaps if I did, I would have got the same loss. Maybe there was something different on the price feeds of those brokers that caused them to generated a S2 trade.
I didn’t get it on my FinFX demo account. It normally tracks well with your live accounts such as the Alpari UK and InterbankFx.
Russ
I got the same bum trade on fxopen ecn account – 85.6 pips.
Hi Richard,
I also had a very bad S2 trade on Ikon Royal:-
S1 buy +10 pips
S2 buy -87 pips
It is strange. I had a very good October +145 pips on this account and then this!!
Hi Chris,
I’ve noticed that I occasionally get losses on one account but not others.
For example, on the 24th I got a 64 pip loss on FxSol that no one else got.
https://www.megadroidresults.com/2011/11/24/megadroid-results-thur-24th-nov-2011/
It’s hard to know why these losses occur on some brokers. Sometimes the historical price data at brokers is different and this can cause a Megadroid trade signal on one broker and not others. At other times excessive slippage prevents a trade being closed that subsequently goes onto a full loss.
Regardless of the reason, if I see a large loss on one broker and not others, that usually makes me suspicious of that broker. That’s one reason why I record my trades carefully.
The thing with Megadroid that’s not really appreciated, is that the containment of the losses is probably more important than the profit trades. This is because the losses, while less frequent, are much larger (50 to 100 pips) than the profit trades (1 to 15 pips).
Craig made a good point about the important of loss minimisation.
(see comment https://www.megadroidresults.com/2011/11/02/november-2011-summary/comment-page-1/#comment-5937)
He made the point that MB Trading’s losses tended to be much less during losing months (e.g. June, July, Aug this year) compared to others, even though it’s profit’s weren’t always at the top of the list during the profit months.