MB Trading : 2 Trades: -18.3 pips
GO Markets : 2 Trades: -19.9 pips
InterbankFx : 1 Trades: -22.5 pips
InterbankFx AU : No Trades
FxPro : 2 Trades: -19.1 pips
Alpari UK (Mini-1) : 2 Trades: -19.7 pips
Alpari UK (Classic): 2 Trades: -17.4 pips
FXDD : 1 Trades: -22.3 pips
AxiTrader : 2 Trades: -18.7 pips
FxSol : 2 Trades: -25.0 pips
TRADE DETAILS: Open Close Profit
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MB Trading S2 Buy: 17:20:14 1.30013 -> 18:20:29 1.30033 2.0 pips
S1 Buy: 16:12:18 1.30111 -> 4:12:22 1.29908 -20.3 pips
GO Markets S1 Buy: 22:12:27 1.30115 -> 10:12:31 1.29898 -21.7 pips
S2 Buy: 23:20:47 1.30011 -> 0:21:00 1.30029 1.8 pips
InterbankFx S1 Buy: 20:12:27 1.30120 -> 8:12:32 1.29895 -22.5 pips
FxPro S2 Buy: 0:20:46 1.30003 -> 1:21:05 1.30033 3.0 pips
S1 Buy: 23:12:54 1.30113 -> 11:12:59 1.29892 -22.1 pips
Alpari UK (Mini-1) S2 Buy: 0:20:14 1.30016 -> 1:20:19 1.30038 2.2 pips
S1 Buy: 23:12:52 1.30111 -> 11:12:56 1.29892 -21.9 pips
Alpari UK (Classic) S2 Buy: 0:20:13 1.30016 -> 1:20:16 1.30039 2.3 pips
S1 Buy: 23:12:04 1.30112 -> 11:12:09 1.29915 -19.7 pips
FXDD S1 Buy: 23:12:53 1.30109 -> 11:12:57 1.29886 -22.3 pips
AxiTrader S2 Buy: 0:20:11 1.30009 -> 1:20:17 1.30037 2.8 pips
S1 Buy: 23:12:27 1.30115 -> 11:12:29 1.29900 -21.5 pips
FxSol S2 Buy: 17:20:44 1.30000 -> 18:21:57 1.30020 2.0 pips
S1 Buy: 16:18:19 1.30090 -> 4:18:29 1.29820 -27.0 pips
Unfortunately I have both S1 and S2 trades open. For currently a total of -65 pips
S2 closed +1.5 pips
S1 Buy still open with -38 pips
Looks like another day of crossing of fingers and knashing of teeth. Keeps things interesting I guess
My S1 trades are still open. Around -43 pips currently. I don’t have any S2 trades open.
I have an open trade with IBFX AU at -36.9 pips.
French
Pour moi aussi buy – 22 pips pour l’instant jais remonté le stop sous la R1 sa commence a faire beaucoup de perte
Seems to be some support at 1.2965
We are sitting on a major fib level, so I think this trade could still be a good one..
We are approaching the 12 hour mark for this trade, where Megadroid has historically closed the trade out regardless of the price. If this occurs… it will be two big losses in a row.
Hi Pete,
It seems the newer version isn’t closing out after 12 hours anymore? (at least in my experience). But for either way, I’ve made my own choice to disable MegaDroid and set TP to BE (I think we have found support and hopefully we’re in an uptrend). Will post my results on how I get on. Also will watch a demo account to see where MD decides to close.
S1 Buy 20:12:52 1.30112 08:12:54 1.29892 -22
Huwee
My First trade IBFX AU… S1 Buy: 20:21:25 1.30114 -> 08:12:27 1.29896 = -21 pips
Still have a S2 open… still have 1 hour before MD closes it out (as it did with the S1) will assess just before the 12 hour make if I’ll do as you did and manually manage this trade.
Sorry… I typed the first time wrong. It should be 20:12:25 ( almost exactly 12 hours prior to the close of the trade)
All my trades have closed. One winner (S2), one loser (S1), total about -20 pips.
Nothing on my IBFX AU account for some reason.
Alpari UK (Classic)
S2 Buy 2.3 pips
S1 Buy -19.7 pips
Total -17.4 pips…
ATC -> -18 pips.(S2-> +2; S1-> -20)
Fxcbs -> -20 pips.
Actually it is rather small loss. But it`a pity anyway. Hope there will be no losses in nearest months.
think that MD team have to be concerned about low volatility of the market, with is the main cause of small amount of trades. Hope they will find a solution soon and MD will recover from May losses.
Pete,
It didn’t make it back up to the entry price and I got stopped out for -60 on my 2nd trade (note to others – I had turned MD off to manage it myself).
EUR/USD is now 1.2924. That’s over 50 pips below my exit price. So in this instance the 12 hour close rule seemed to be beneficial. A 20 pip loss is recoverable.
The European situation is still impacting the market significantly.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304070304577393611782085418.html
Difficult trading conditions.
Fx Primus
+2.5
-20.3
🙁
FinFX: -22.6pips
If we look to the last months where MD traded I think the market IS changed and MD isn’t a right choice at this moment. Why I think this?!…. well this is the result of the last +/- 2 months:
9 trades => 7BE and 2 loss
So actually 9 times in a row MD was wrong!!
Thereby… MD needed some change in pips at tradingtime. And in this period the Asian-market is reacting at an otherway then in the past!!
I’m thinking of shuting down MD for a while and waiting for a better time… Is my reaction a valid one?!
FXDD 1 trade -22.1 pips
IBFX 2 trades +2.4 (with $3.47 Swap) and -22.5 for net of -20.1
Hi Peter,
I’m personally continuing unchanged.
Just for record keeping, I thought I’d post the chart of this trade (see below). In this case closing at the 12 hour mark probably saved about 40 pips or so.